It can be quite challenging to find the best car insurance in New York. Many individuals find themselves in a situation where selecting a company feels like blindly throwing darts at a dartboard. This holds true regardless of whether you reside in bustling Manhattan or the serene surroundings of the Finger Lakes region. Fortunately, we have taken the initiative to conduct thorough research on your behalf.
The top car insurance companies in New York provide a wide selection of coverage options at reasonable prices. This article will thoroughly examine the five leading insurers in New York, providing detailed insights into customer satisfaction and industry reputation.
Bankrate conducted a thorough analysis of various factors, including average premium data from Quadrant Information Services, coverage options, discounts, and more. Based on this evaluation, Geico, USAA, Progressive, State Farm, and Allstate emerged as the top car insurance companies in New York. To ensure comprehensive assessment, we also considered AM Best financial strength ratings and customer satisfaction scores from the 2023 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Insurance Study. It is worth noting that most of the companies on our list offer annual premiums that are below the New York average of $3,751 for full coverage and $1,605 for minimum coverage.
It is crucial to safeguard your investment when purchasing or leasing a car. Auto insurance provides peace of mind by covering expenses in the event of accidents, theft, vandalism, or damage caused by natural disasters. By paying annual premiums to an auto insurance company, individuals can avoid out-of-pocket expenses for auto incidents, as the company will cover a significant portion, if not all, of the costs related to vehicle damage or accidents.
Car insurance functions as a formal agreement between an individual and an insurance provider, wherein the individual commits to paying premiums in return for protection against financial losses resulting from a car accident or any other form of damage to the vehicle. Auto insurance can provide coverage for various aspects, such as vehicle damages (whether to your own car or another driver’s vehicle), property damage, bodily injuries caused by an accident, as well as medical bills and funeral expenses related to injuries sustained in a collision. The specific coverage details are contingent upon the minimum coverage mandates in your state and any additional coverage selections you opt for. With the exception of New Hampshire, all states mandate drivers to carry a minimum level of bodily injury liability coverage and property damage liability coverage.
Best Car Insurance in New York
Our study revealed that State Farm provides the most competitive car insurance in New York. Upon evaluating the leading auto insurance companies in the state, we discovered that Geico, Travelers, Progressive, and Allstate are also highly recommended options for car insurance in New York.
New York Auto Insurance can be compared to determine the best option for your needs
We conducted a thorough comparison of auto insurance providers in New York, evaluating factors such as pricing, customer satisfaction, reputation, and coverage options to identify the top performers. Here are the results of our analysis:
1. State Farm: Our score – 9.3
Reputation – 9.6
Availability – 9.7
Coverage – 8.9
Cost – 9.2
Customer Experience – 9.4
2. Geico: Our score – 9.1
Reputation – 9.8
Availability – 10
Coverage – 8.3
Cost – 9.2
Customer Experience – 8.9
3. Travelers: Our score – 9
Reputation – 8.6
Availability – 9.8
Coverage – 9.3
Cost – 8.8
Customer Experience – 8.8
4. Progressive: Our score – 8.7
Reputation – 8
Availability – 10
Coverage – 8.8
Cost – 8.7
Customer Experience – 8.6
5. Allstate: Our score – 8.7
Reputation – 9.4
Availability – 10
Coverage – 8.8
Cost – 6.5
Customer Experience – 8.5
These rankings provide insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each provider, helping consumers make informed decisions when selecting auto insurance in New York.
Customer Experience
Our team conducted a thorough analysis of customer satisfaction with the leading insurance companies by referring to our car insurance satisfaction study conducted in August 2022. This study involved surveying nearly 7,000 drivers to gather their feedback. Additionally, we considered the evaluations provided by industry studies, which included the ratings and customer reviews from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), the financial strength ratings from AM Best, and the consumer studies conducted by J.D. Power.
Is State Farm Insurance considered to be of high quality?
Our comprehensive analysis concluded that State Farm stands out as the top car insurance option for drivers in New York. Renowned for its competitive pricing, the company’s average full-coverage policy is approximately 14% cheaper than the national average.
Additionally, State Farm provides a wide range of discounts and telematics insurance programs to help reduce expenses. Young drivers under the age of 25 can take advantage of the Steer Clear® program to lower their premiums. Moreover, the Drive Safe & Save™ usage-based program assists policyholders in securing discounted rates.
Advantages:
1. A++ financial strength rating from AM Best, indicating a high level of financial stability and reliability.
2. Offers good discount opportunities for students and teens, making coverage more affordable for younger drivers.
3. Enjoys a stellar reputation for customer service, with a track record of responsive and helpful assistance.
Disadvantage:
1. Mixed State Farm insurance reviews suggest that while many customers are satisfied with their experience, others may have encountered issues or concerns.
State Farm Car Insurance Coverage
State Farm, as per the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), stands as the largest car insurance provider in the nation. Their full-coverage car insurance extends beyond basic liability coverage to include bodily injury liability and property damage liability coverage. Typically, State Farm’s full-coverage policies encompass:
1. Collision insurance: Covers damages to your vehicle resulting from collisions with other vehicles or objects.
2. Comprehensive insurance: Protects against non-collision incidents such as theft, vandalism, or natural disasters.
3. Medical payments coverage (MedPay): Assists with medical expenses for you and your passengers, regardless of fault.
4. Underinsured/uninsured motorist coverage: Offers protection if you’re involved in an accident with a driver who lacks sufficient insurance coverage.
In addition to these core coverages, State Farm offers several supplemental auto insurance options, including:
1. Rideshare insurance: Provides coverage for drivers who work for ride-sharing services like Uber or Lyft.
2. Roadside assistance: Offers support for common roadside issues such as flat tires, dead batteries, or towing needs.
3. Rental car reimbursement: Helps cover the cost of renting a replacement vehicle if your car is in the shop for covered repairs.
4. Trip interruption coverage: Offers financial protection if your trip is interrupted due to a covered incident, such as a car accident.
These additional coverage options allow State Farm customers to tailor their policies to suit their specific needs and preferences.
State Farm Insurance Company Reputation
State Farm consistently performs exceptionally well in consumer studies conducted by J.D. Power. According to the latest J.D. Power 2022 U.S. Auto Insurance Study℠, State Farm secured the second position in terms of overall customer satisfaction in New York, surpassing the regional average by a significant margin of nine points. Furthermore, State Farm emerged as the top scorer among large insurers in the J.D. Power 2022 U.S. Insurance Shopping Study℠, achieving an impressive score of 885 out of 1,000 points.
Our August 2022 survey revealed that a notable 19% of respondents held car insurance policies with State Farm. This popular insurer garnered a commendable 4.2-star rating out of 5.0 for overall customer satisfaction, aligning with the survey’s average rating.
Is Geico Insurance Good?
Geico, following State Farm, holds the position of the second-largest auto insurer in the country, with a market share of 14.31% in 2021. Our research indicates that Geico is recognized as one of the most affordable car insurance providers nationwide. On average, their comprehensive insurance plans amount to $109 per month or $1,308 per year, making them approximately 24% less expensive than the national average.
Moreover, Geico is renowned for its extensive coverage limits and a wide range of discounts. These discounts encompass special rates for diligent students, individuals who have recently purchased a new vehicle, and responsible drivers.
Advantages
– A++ financial strength rating by AM Best and A+ rating by the BBB
– Generous policy limits
– Competitive car insurance premiums for the majority of drivers
Disadvantages
– Average J.D. Power claims ratings
– Fewer local agents compared to other insurers.
Geico Car Insurance Coverage
Geico provides the six fundamental types of car insurance typically found in comprehensive auto insurance policies. Furthermore, the company offers beneficial additional options such as Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI), Rental Car Reimbursement, Roadside Assistance, and Rideshare Insurance.
Geico Insurance Company Reputation
Geico demonstrates outstanding financial stability, as indicated by its AM Best rating. The company’s favorable rating from the BBB and its impressive performance in the J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study reflect its dedication to providing exceptional customer service.
In our recent 2022 survey, sixteen percent of participants disclosed that they are insured by Geico. These policyholders rated Geico an average of 4.1 out of 5.0 stars for their satisfaction with the customer service provided.
Is Travelers Insurance considered to be of high quality?
Travelers is highly regarded in the car insurance sector due to its competitive rates and efficient handling of claims. Additionally, customers appreciate the various savings options offered by Travelers. Among these is the Early Quote discount, which allows policyholders to enjoy reduced rates by obtaining a quote from Travelers before their current policy with another insurance provider expires.
Advantages:
Positive AM Best and BBB ratings
Numerous discounts offered
Accident forgiveness included
Disadvantage:
Poor customer rating on the BBB website.
Travelers Car Insurance Coverage
Travelers offers a comprehensive range of insurance options, in addition to the standard coverage types. These optional coverages include:
1. Rental car coverage
2. Gap insurance
3. New car replacement coverage
4. Accident forgiveness coverage
5. Two levels of roadside assistance.
Travelers Insurance Company Reputation
In spite of receiving favorable ratings from AM Best and the BBB, Travelers exhibits varying scores in J.D. Power studies. According to the regional J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study, Travelers performed on par with the industry average in terms of overall customer satisfaction in New York. However, in the J.D. Power Insurance Shopping Study, the company ranked last among large insurers in customer satisfaction, earning a total of 853 out of 1,000 possible points.
Merely approximately 1.5% of participants in our 2022 car insurance survey reported being policyholders with Travelers. Nevertheless, those who did possess policies expressed considerable satisfaction with the company, awarding it a rating of 4.2 stars out of 5.0.
Is Progressive Insurance considered to be of high quality?
Progressive, being the third-largest auto insurance company in the market, presents itself as an ideal option for high-risk drivers. In particular, residents of New York who have experienced at-fault accidents, recent speeding tickets, or DUIs in their driving history can benefit from Progressive’s competitive and affordable rates.
One notable feature that Progressive offers is accident forgiveness, catering to both minor and major incidents. For new policyholders, Progressive provides automatic small accident forgiveness, ensuring that their insurance rates remain unaffected if their claim does not surpass $500. This demonstrates Progressive’s commitment to providing comprehensive coverage and financial stability to its customers.
Advantages
– A top-tier financial strength rating by AM Best
– Extensive range of coverage choices
– Exceptionally rated mobile application
Disadvantages
– Mediocre customer service rating.
Progressive Car Insurance Coverage
Progressive, like other major insurance companies, offers a range of standard auto insurance coverage options as well as additional add-ons. These offerings encompass services such as roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, loan/lease payoff coverage (also known as gap insurance), coverage for custom parts and equipment value, rideshare coverage, pet coverage, and the Deductible Savings Bank.
Progressive Insurance Company Reputation
Progressive consistently falls below average in consumer studies conducted by J.D. Power. In the J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study, the company scored 11 points lower than the regional average in New York. Additionally, Progressive received a lower score than the average for large insurers in the J.D. Power Insurance Shopping Study, earning 859 points out of 1,000.
Our review team made an effort to contact Progressive for a comment regarding these scores and its BBB rating, but unfortunately, we did not receive a response.
Despite the low ratings in the industry, Progressive remains the second-most popular car insurance provider according to our consumer survey. Approximately 17% of participants reported having Progressive policies, and they gave the insurer an average customer satisfaction rating of 4.1 out of 5.0 stars.
Is Allstate Insurance recommended?
Allstate ranks as the fourth-largest car insurance provider in the nation, as per the NAIC. If you are dissatisfied with how the company manages your claim, they offer a claim satisfaction guarantee that can refund up to six months of insurance premiums. Additionally, the Allstate Rewards® program promotes safe driving behaviors by providing gift cards and shopping rewards based on a points system.
Advantages
– AM Best has awarded them an A+ financial strength rating.
– They provide a claim satisfaction guarantee.
– They offer a wide range of insurance coverage options.
Disadvantages
– Their prices are frequently higher than the average.
– Customer reviews are mixed.
Allstate Car Insurance Coverage
In addition to the six standard types of car insurance coverage, Allstate provides a wide range of supplementary coverage options and discount programs. These encompass aftermarket parts insurance, classic car insurance, insurance for travel to Mexico and Canada, rideshare insurance, and roadside assistance coverage. Furthermore, Allstate offers Extended Vehicle Care, a service contract program that offers three coverage tiers resembling extended warranties. These tiers assist in covering the expenses related to mechanical breakdowns. Moreover, Allstate’s Deductible Rewards® program lowers your deductible for every year you remain accident-free.
Allstate Insurance Reputation
Allstate typically performs below average in consumer surveys. In the J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study, the company obtained the second-lowest score in New York. However, Allstate showed slight improvement in the J.D. Power Insurance Shopping Study, achieving a score of 854 out of 1,000 points, placing it nine points below the industry average.
Our team contacted Allstate for a statement regarding these ratings, but unfortunately, we did not receive a response.
Approximately 9% of respondents in our 2022 car insurance poll reported having Allstate policies. Overall, they expressed satisfaction with the company, giving it an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.0 stars.
How To Find the Best Car Insurance in New York
Start your search for car insurance coverage in New York by taking into account a few crucial factors, and you will realize that obtaining the best insurance is not excessively difficult. Here are some recommendations to assist you in finding the most affordable rates in New York.
Consider New York State Minimum Requirements
Before commencing your search for car insurance, it is essential to be aware of the minimum car insurance requirements set by the state. In New York, the minimum coverage mandated includes:
– Bodily injury liability: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident
– Property damage liability: $10,000 per accident
– Uninsured motorist coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident
– Personal injury protection (PIP insurance): $50,000 per person
New York operates as a no-fault state, meaning that your insurance provider will handle your medical expenses and compensate for lost wages, irrespective of fault in an accident.
Decide What Coverage You Need
Before obtaining car insurance quotes and finalizing your coverage with an insurance agent, it is important to take into account specific factors. Your location and the individuals you are insuring will significantly impact the types of coverage you receive and the amount required for each.
For instance, residing in a region of New York prone to blizzards during winter may necessitate purchasing comprehensive coverage to safeguard your vehicle against potential weather-related harm. Comprehensive insurance is also beneficial for drivers in urban areas with high rates of auto theft.
Teen drivers have a higher likelihood of being involved in car accidents. Therefore, if you are considering insuring your teen driver’s vehicle, PIP insurance will cover any injuries sustained. Additionally, collision insurance will address damages to your teen’s car.
Know Your Lender’s Requirements
Lenders and lessors frequently demand higher levels of car insurance coverage compared to the minimum requirements set by the state of New York. In the event that you are financing or leasing a vehicle, it might be necessary for you to acquire a comprehensive insurance policy.
Average Cost of Car Insurance in New York
According to statistics provided by Quadrant Information Services, the typical expense for a comprehensive car insurance plan in New York is $232 monthly or $2,783 annually. This amount is approximately 61% higher than the nationwide average of $1,730 per year. These figures pertain to a 35-year-old married driver with a favorable credit rating and a spotless driving history.
New York Car Insurance Costs by City
Here are the average rates for full-coverage car insurance policies for a 35-year-old driver in 18 cities across New York state:
City Monthly Average Annual Average
– Greece: $106 $1,267
– Albany: $112 $1,344
– Rochester: $115 $1,384
– Syracuse: $122 $1,458
– Tonawanda: $129 $1,544
– Cheektowaga: $129 $1,546
– Buffalo: $159 $1,910
– New Rochelle: $165 $1,977
– Brookhaven: $177 $2,124
– Smithtown: $181 $2,172
– Huntington: $189 $2,268
– Oyster Bay: $192 $2,308
– Yonkers: $194 $2,332
– Babylon: $197 $2,361
– Islip: $197 $2,364
– Mount Vernon: $218 $2,621
– New York City: $228 $2,734
– Hempstead: $264 $3,170
These rates provide an overview of the varying costs of car insurance across different cities in New York.
Car Insurance Discounts in New York
When searching for the most affordable car insurance, it is advisable to inquire with insurers regarding the discounts they offer. Below are a few examples of the typical car insurance discounts available in New York.
- Good Student Savings
Many leading car insurance companies provide discounts of at least 10% to students who maintain a B grade average or higher. Given that car insurance premiums tend to be highest for young drivers, it is worth checking whether you or your teenage driver are eligible for this discount. - Theft Prevention Savings
In order to promote the adoption of safety measures, numerous insurers offer discounts to car owners who equip their vehicles with anti-theft devices such as car alarms and glass-break sensors. - Automatic Payment Savings
With a large number of policies to manage, major insurance companies incur significant costs in printing materials and bills. Consequently, many providers now offer discounts to customers who opt for paperless billing and set up automatic payments online.
Conclusion
Although health and homeowner’s insurance may appear to be more crucial, owning an automobile necessitates having an insurance policy. Regardless of whether your state mandates auto insurance, it is essential as it can potentially save you a significant amount of money and frustration in the future. It is advisable to explore various car insurance rates to secure the necessary coverage at an affordable price.
Read more >>How to Get Car Insurance For Foreign Drivers in USA | Best Guide
State Farm, Geico, Travelers, Progressive, and Allstate are the top-rated car insurance companies in New York. Our 2022 car insurance survey has shown that each of these providers received excellent ratings. Additionally, they have all been recognized for their strong financial stability by AM Best. Moreover, these five companies offer a diverse selection of insurance coverage options and provide numerous discounts to their customers.